Original question
here.
Quoted from halfvolley in post #47986
Can any Zimbabwe fan explain me what is the role of Medhevere in the team ? Surely there are better players out there?
Wessly Madhevere is supposed to be the next great batsman in Zimbabwe cricket. The word "potential" gets thrown around a lot whenever his name comes up. I'm a numbers guy, and I've never been particularly impressed by this obsession with potential. You either perform or you don't. So, rather than speculate about what Wes might become, let's examine what he has actually achieved.
The first number is
26. That's Wes' age. He's not a kid anymore. I'm happy to entertain discussions about potential when we're talking about someone like Shelton Mazvitorera. But at 26, with more than six years of international cricket behind him, Wes should have a pretty good understanding of his game by now.
The next two numbers are
63 and 28.3. If we define a batting failure as an innings of 20 or fewer runs, and a success as an innings of 30 or more, Wes has a failure rate of
63% and a success rate of just
28.3% in ODIs.
In Tests, his failure rate drops slightly to
58%, while his success rate is approximately
26%.
In other words, in both formats, Wes fails to make 20 in nearly six out of every ten innings, while producing a score of 30 or more in barely one out of four. I'll leave you to decide what those numbers say about his batting.
Now, some people will undoubtedly point to his performances in the first Test against Afghanistan as a turning point. He scored a 50 and followed it up with his maiden international century. Perhaps he has finally figured something out. Perhaps this is the big turning point we have all been waiting for.
Or perhaps, just perhaps, it was a fluke.
That wicket was flatter than a tyre after an encounter with Harare's potholes. Everyone was scoring runs on it. Even Tsiga got in on the act!
One good Test doesn't erase years of underwhelming performances. Equally, it would be foolish to dismiss the possibility that Wes is finally improving.
Now, to your first question about his role in the team. Wes is a middle order batsman who also bowls useful offies. Beyond that, he is well liked by the people running Zimbabwe cricket. I'm not going to get into the reasons because it will lengthen what is already a long post.
The point is that he appears to enjoy a level of selection security that his batting numbers don't necessarily justify. I'm not here to argue against his selection. I'll let the numbers do the arguing.
As for your second question, are there better players in Zimbabwe's domestic system? Personally, I don't think so. Johnathan Campbell is probably his closest competition, but his domestic batting numbers aren't particularly impressive either. On current form, I'd pick Wes ahead of him any day of the week.
Perhaps my assessment of Wes comes across as a little harsh, so let me offer something in his defence.
I believe his development as a batsman has been hampered by the fact that he rarely gets an opportunity to bat in the top 5.
Right now, the 40 year olds have their geriatric claws firmly wrapped around the middle order positions. As a result, Wes generally finds himself batting at 6 or 7, positions that some argue are too low for him.
There may be something to that argument. A consistent opportunity higher up the order might allow him to develop into a more productive batsman. Again, the numbers will eventually tell us.
Zimbabwe will soon have to replace the ageing batsmen who have carried much of the batting responsibility for years. Wes is supposed to be part of that next generation.
At some point, we need to stop talking about what he might become and start judging him by what he actually delivers.
Potential doesn't put runs on the scoreboard. Performance does.