Squad's out, not the most promising again.
Raza (Captain)
Blessing
Brian
Evans
Taylor
Ervine
Masuku
Newman
Burl
Marumani
Tsiga
Masekasa
Madhevere
Out: Kaia, Cremer
In: Masekasa, Tsiga
Series
Series Discussion: Zimbabwe Tour of the UAE | 2026 Oct 17 - 2026 Nov 17
Series/Tournament Pinned
Show flagship post
Quoted from zimbot in post #47492
ODI tri-series KEEP or DITCH:
Bennett - Now that there is lots of footage, everybody seems to have a plan to get him out. He needs to make some technical and mental adjustments or move down the order.
Verdict: KEEP.
Curran - He hasn't played an innings of significance in unfamiliar conditions. He is quite limited as a player and top sides always work out how to get him out. I would stick with him for now, but he needs to sort out his game.
Verdict: KEEP (hanging by a thread)
Marumani - For all the hype, I have never seen this guy perform. Does he even have an international 50 against quality opposition? He's been around for a while, therefore inexperience cannot be used as an excuse. He hasn't done anything to show that he can hang with the big boys. The alternatives are no better, so I guess we are stuck with him.
Verdict: KEEP (it's him or Madande)
Tsiga - Let's put an end to this experiment for now. Not good enough for the role they gave him. Innocent Kaia should replace him when he recovers.
Verdict: DITCH!
Taylor - Showed that he still has a bit of fire left in him in the first game. Against Afghanistan, he was poor. He also deserves credit for his keeping. He was excellent in the Arabian heat. Let's stick with him.
Verdict: KEEP.
Ervine - Steady and reliable. Recently, he's been our best player. We are going to struggle when he retires.
Verdict: KEEP.
Raza - Great series with the bat. On all three occassions, he had to come in and to do some repairwork after a top order collapse and did exceptionally well. Not going to comment on his bowling because somehow, I didn't get the chance to watch him bowl.
Verdict: KEEP.
Burl - Did ok. But let's be honest, compared to Ervive, he is a massive downgrade. He can absorb pressure, rotate the strike to keep the game moving, but a stupid shot is always around the corner. Despite that, he has leapfrogged Wes who, in my opinion, is not good enough for international cricket.
Verdict: KEEP
Madhevere - Get rid of this guy already. Give his spot to Johnathan Campbell.
Verdict: DITCH!
Evans - Not a new ball bowler! Or maybe he struggled because of the heat? Great game against Bangladesh, but poor against Afghanistan. With the bat, he proved that promoting him would be a bad idea. Not his best series, but he's good player.
Verdict: KEEP
Newman - With the ball, he did ok. Nothing spectacular. I like the aggression that he showed against Afghanistan. Let's hope he continues to grow. With the bat, he has loads of potential.
Verdict: KEEP
Wellington - I have been calling for his head for a while, but my position has shifted a bit. Sure, he isn't going to rip through the opposition, but he does offer a level of control that other spinners don't. In addition, he has a tendency to nick a wicket or two at crucial times.
Verdict: KEEP
Masuku - He was excellent in the only game he played. He kept the scoring rate down in the middle overs and took wickets. Despite that, if everyone is fit, I don't think he makes the XI. Good to have in the squad though.
Verdict: KEEP
Blessing - No explanation needed.
Verdict: KEEP
Overall Verdict: for all the noise being made about the 40 year olds, none of the younger guys are good enough. Gentlemen, our team is going to be s**t after the 2027 World Cup.
Thomas Purcell
Member actions
ShareVeteran
What a finish to the tour
But the test series has eclipsed what was a dismal limited overs leg though.
Still, good to walk away with something, and an away test series win is right up there
But the test series has eclipsed what was a dismal limited overs leg though.
Still, good to walk away with something, and an away test series win is right up there
Zimbabwe fan, long time lurker on the old ZCF
Member actions
ShareVeteran
Well that was one scintillating end to the tour, a fitting way to wrap up 2026.
But, lets do a recap shall we? The test series did eclipse the limited overs leg. A quick look at how people went about this tour?
But, lets do a recap shall we? The test series did eclipse the limited overs leg. A quick look at how people went about this tour?
Zimbabwe fan, long time lurker on the old ZCF
Member actions
ShareZCF Original
Quoted from AusBiggestZimCricFan in post #47852
Quoted from zimbot in post #47492
ODI tri-series KEEP or DITCH:
Bennett - Now that there is lots of footage, everybody seems to have a plan to get him out. He needs to make some technical and mental adjustments or move down the order.
Verdict: KEEP.
Curran - He hasn't played an innings of significance in unfamiliar conditions. He is quite limited as a player and top sides always work out how to get him out. I would stick with him for now, but he needs to sort out his game.
Verdict: KEEP (hanging by a thread)
Marumani - For all the hype, I have never seen this guy perform. Does he even have an international 50 against quality opposition? He's been around for a while, therefore inexperience cannot be used as an excuse. He hasn't done anything to show that he can hang with the big boys. The alternatives are no better, so I guess we are stuck with him.
Verdict: KEEP (it's him or Madande)
Tsiga - Let's put an end to this experiment for now. Not good enough for the role they gave him. Innocent Kaia should replace him when he recovers.
Verdict: DITCH!
Taylor - Showed that he still has a bit of fire left in him in the first game. Against Afghanistan, he was poor. He also deserves credit for his keeping. He was excellent in the Arabian heat. Let's stick with him.
Verdict: KEEP.
Ervine - Steady and reliable. Recently, he's been our best player. We are going to struggle when he retires.
Verdict: KEEP.
Raza - Great series with the bat. On all three occassions, he had to come in and to do some repairwork after a top order collapse and did exceptionally well. Not going to comment on his bowling because somehow, I didn't get the chance to watch him bowl.
Verdict: KEEP.
Burl - Did ok. But let's be honest, compared to Ervive, he is a massive downgrade. He can absorb pressure, rotate the strike to keep the game moving, but a stupid shot is always around the corner. Despite that, he has leapfrogged Wes who, in my opinion, is not good enough for international cricket.
Verdict: KEEP
Madhevere - Get rid of this guy already. Give his spot to Johnathan Campbell.
Verdict: DITCH!
Evans - Not a new ball bowler! Or maybe he struggled because of the heat? Great game against Bangladesh, but poor against Afghanistan. With the bat, he proved that promoting him would be a bad idea. Not his best series, but he's good player.
Verdict: KEEP
Newman - With the ball, he did ok. Nothing spectacular. I like the aggression that he showed against Afghanistan. Let's hope he continues to grow. With the bat, he has loads of potential.
Verdict: KEEP
Wellington - I have been calling for his head for a while, but my position has shifted a bit. Sure, he isn't going to rip through the opposition, but he does offer a level of control that other spinners don't. In addition, he has a tendency to nick a wicket or two at crucial times.
Verdict: KEEP
Masuku - He was excellent in the only game he played. He kept the scoring rate down in the middle overs and took wickets. Despite that, if everyone is fit, I don't think he makes the XI. Good to have in the squad though.
Verdict: KEEP
Blessing - No explanation needed.
Verdict: KEEP
Overall Verdict: for all the noise being made about the 40 year olds, none of the younger guys are good enough. Gentlemen, our team is going to be s**t after the 2027 World Cup.
Afghanistan is a peculiar opposition: one of world best T20 squads (much beyond Zimbabwe skills), on the other hand a playable opposition in Tests.
Hence the tour results are twofold and difficult to compare.
In the latest test none of the three Raza, Ervine and of course Williams were there. A few years ago everybody was speculating how bleak the future would have been without them.
Surely there's been the important addition of Brendan Taylor and Cremer.
True that the squad has still to rely on players over 40 years old. In my opinion they may have a comfortable two-three years of competitive cricket ahead.
Antun Naqvi has been a question mark: let's see him again
Member actions
Share